Press Release: CSAN Responds to the Milburn Report 

CSAN urges the UK government to promote dignity, inclusion, and human flourishing for all young people in youth employment reforms. 

CSAN welcomes today’s launch of the report, From a Welfare State to a Working State by Alan Milburn, in its commitment to supporting young people’s futures, and in recognising some of the systemic factors which have led to 13% of young people in the UK being not in education or training (‘NEET’).1 However, we have significant concerns about the young people who will fall through the gaps in these proposals, and about the use of these proposals to justify cuts to social security protections for young Disabled people.

In May, Caritas Social Action Network (CSAN) published a report, Dignity of Workers in the 21st Century which included a commitment “to support young people to enter the workforce with dignity”.2 Catholic Social Teaching points clearly towards the importance of meaningful, dignified work for all. In Laborem Exercens, Pope John Paul II highlights the vocational nature of work – for the benefit of God’s creation, personal development and the wider community. Consequently, we are relieved to see the many thousands of young people being taken seriously by government ministers, particularly through the Youth Jobs Guarantee, doubling apprenticeships, and the commitment to a 10-year strategy rather than a short-term fix. 

However, Milburn’s recommendations do not promote dignity for all. We are concerned about the false dichotomy the report presents between supporting people into work and providing social security. A strong social security system is essential for everyone throughout our lives, and provides us all with a safety net if we lose our jobs or are unable to work. We are particularly conscious of the impact of this rhetoric and the proposed policies on young Disabled people.

We are also concerned about recommendations that would rewards businesses for offering low paid work or insecure work, and that propose a “cautionary principle” when extending rights to young workers such as guaranteed hours. We do not believe that young workers should have fewer rights or less dignified work than others.

The report also fails to consider the unequal geographic distribution of opportunities; and the deeper questions about an economic model which fails to give young people hope.3 Despite recognising that young people face “a future of uncertainty as artificial intelligence and automation reshape the world of work”, the report fails to consider the need to protect entry-level roles with more stringent AI policies.4 Finally, the report also neglects to ask questions about the types of work being offered to young people, such as the missed opportunity for green jobs.5 

It is reassuring to see a call to action for young people in the “lost generation”, but the report’s proposed solutions fail to promote and protect dignity and human flourishing for every young person equally. 

CSAN is currently undertaking a conversation with its network of fifty Catholic charities and diocesan Caritas agencies to put together a longer reflection on the report, including those working with young Disabled people whom these proposals will disproportionately impact.  

Notes to Editors 

  • Caritas Social Action Network (CSAN) is the domestic social action agency of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales. 
  • CSAN convenes and supports a network of 50+ charities involved in the social mission of the Church. Its mission is to tackle the causes of poverty, promote justice and restore dignity through collaboration, formation and public advocacy. 
  • Inspired by Catholic Social Teaching, CSAN’s work is grounded in the dignity of every person, the preferential option for the poor, the common good, subsidiarity and solidarity. 
  • CSAN works towards communities in which every person can flourish, the voices of people experiencing vulnerability are heard and everyone is encouraged to contribute to the common good. 
  • CSAN is a national member of Caritas Internationalis within Caritas Europa. England and Wales have two national Caritas members: CAFOD, which focuses on international development, and CSAN, which focuses on domestic social action. 
  • Caritas Social Action Network is a registered charity in England and Wales (1101431) and a company limited by guarantee (4505111). 
  • Media enquiries: erica.lees-smith@csan.org.uk 

[1] Young people not in education, employment or training (NEET), UK – Office for National Statistics

[2] https://www.csan.org.uk/csan-launches-dignity-of-workers-in-the-21st-century-publication/

[3] https://www.ippr.org/articles/a-better-deal

[4] From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation – GOV.UK; The Growing Threat to Entry-Level Jobs in the Age of AI  – British Chambers of Commerce

[5]https://www.gndrising.org/jobs-for-our-future/